Cuomo vs. Mamdani: The battle that could redefine the democratic party
New York City stands at the precipice of a political transformation as Assemblymember Zohran Mamdani, an avowed democratic socialist, edges closer to unseating former Governor Andrew Cuomo in the Democratic primary for mayor. A Mamdani victory would not only upend the city’s political status quo but also signal a watershed moment for the national left and the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), testing whether the ideology can translate from insurgency to governance.
Mamdani’s victory would signal seismic shift in national politics—and a crucial test for the socialist movement.
Getty Images
Once viewed as a long-shot, Mamdani’s rapid ascent has caught national attention. He now trails Cuomo by single digits in several polls, defying a $25 million ad blitz funded by billionaire-backed super PACs. Should Mamdani clinch the primary and go on to win the general election, he would become the first democratic socialist to govern America’s largest city, managing a $115 billion budget and overseeing over 300,000 city workers.
“Having the largest city in the country led by a socialist mayor would send a powerful and empowering message to socialists and working-class movements nationwide,” said Grace Mausser, co-chair of NYC’s DSA chapter.
But governing New York is among the most complex political tasks in the U.S., a challenge that has humbled far more centrist figures. Mamdani, a 33-year-old state legislator first elected in 2020, has pledged to freeze rents on one million regulated apartments, tax the ultra-wealthy to fund free public transit, and introduce city-owned grocery stores—measures that resonate with progressives but demand legislative battles in Albany and careful fiscal navigation.
Skeptics point to the experience of Chicago’s Brandon Johnson, another DSA-aligned mayor, who has faced policy setbacks and declining approval ratings. The Chicago Tribune recently warned New Yorkers: “Want to know how a socialist mayor would govern New York City? Ask Chicago.”
Critics argue that Johnson’s ideology led to mismanagement and political paralysis. Mamdani’s supporters counter that his coalition-building and outreach—including meetings with former municipal leaders like Maria Torres-Springer and Steven Banks—demonstrate his intent to govern pragmatically.
“Zohran has worked across ideological lines to deliver real results,” said Elle Bisgaard-Church, Mamdani’s campaign manager. “His record shows he knows how to organize, persuade, and lead.”
Mamdani’s campaign also distinguishes itself by unprecedented grassroots energy, boasting over 45,000 volunteers and mobilizing disillusioned urban voters. Cea Weaver, leader of NYS Tenant Bloc, estimates her organization alone has delivered 20,000 votes for Mamdani through door-to-door outreach.
The symbolic weight of defeating Cuomo—a veteran of New York politics with deep institutional support—adds to the magnitude of Mamdani’s rise. His candidacy has drawn endorsements from progressive icons Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, both of whom see his bid as an extension of their own populist missions.
But the challenges ahead are steep. Mamdani will face resistance from moderates, including Governor Kathy Hochul, who has already rejected his proposed tax increases. And he must convince skeptics that socialist ideals can survive the crucible of municipal governance.
“The real test isn’t whether Mamdani can win—it’s whether he can govern,” said John Franco, a former aide in Bernie Sanders’ mayoral administration. “You can’t talk about systemic change if you can’t plow the streets.”
If victorious, Mamdani’s tenure will become a high-stakes experiment for the American left. It will measure whether a grassroots-driven, ideologically bold coalition can translate popular support into durable governance. And it will determine whether the energy of a movement can meet the demands of managing potholes, police unions, and power brokers—all under the brightest political spotlight in the country.
