'The Old Guard 2' review: Netflix's action sequel returns with immortal drama, Charlize Theron, and uneven execution
Netflix struck gold with The Old Guard in 2020, offering an electrifying fusion of action, myth, and emotional complexity. At the center was Charlize Theron’s Andy, a battle-hardened immortal warrior burdened by centuries of solitude. Under the direction of Gina Prince-Bythewood, the film became more than just a stylish superhero story—it resonated as an introspective meditation on pain, loyalty, and purpose.
Charlize Theron in 'The Old Guard 2.'
Courtesy of Netflix
Five years later, The Old Guard 2 returns with much of its original cast intact. Charlize Theron, KiKi Layne, Marwan Kenzari, and Luca Marinelli all reprise their roles, joined by new characters who expand the immortal mythology. The sequel brings fresh environments, elevated action sequences, and new threats. Yet the absence of Prince-Bythewood’s visionary direction creates a subtle shift—one that makes this installment feel technically sound but less emotionally grounded.
Victoria Mahoney, who directed episodes for acclaimed series and worked on Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, takes over behind the camera. Her approach is sharp, and the action choreography is clean and kinetic. A standout opening set-piece, shot in a stunning villa on Lake Como, showcases high-octane gunfire, hand-to-hand combat, and a well-timed car chase. This thrilling sequence sets a high bar that the rest of the film struggles to match.
The core narrative resumes from the aftermath of the first film. Andy has lost her immortality. Booker remains exiled for betraying the team. CIA agent Copley, now an ally, continues protecting their identities and channeling their efforts toward morally justified missions. Emotional baggage from centuries of violence still hangs heavy over every member of the squad.
Newly reintroduced is Quynh, Andy’s ancient companion thought lost to the sea. Buried alive and forced to drown repeatedly for over 500 years, Quynh has resurfaced with vengeance and betrayal in her heart. Her grudge against humanity—and against Andy—becomes a central conflict. Rather than reuniting with warmth, Quynh returns as a psychological and physical adversary.
The narrative also brings in fresh mythology. Henry Golding plays Tuah, a former immortal warrior turned scholar who has spent lifetimes chronicling the group's hidden impact on world history. His vast library holds not only secrets but connections to a new antagonist: Uma Thurman’s Discord. This ancient, enigmatic immortal predates even Andy. She operates from the shadows, amassing power and manipulating events through centuries of strategic silence.
Charlize Theron remains the heart of the film. Her portrayal of Andy is once again defined by exhaustion, strength, and dry wit. As Nile, KiKi Layne brings confidence and emotional grounding. Their relationship grows into a partnership defined by mutual respect and tempered wisdom. Layne’s performance brings welcome levity to otherwise grim stakes, and her character arc continues to evolve meaningfully.
Joe and Nicky, portrayed by Marwan Kenzari and Luca Marinelli, maintain their quiet magnetism. Their long-standing romance was a highlight of the original film, offering rare, unambiguous queer representation in a genre that often shies away from such intimacy. This time, the emotional moments are more subdued. One near-romantic scene fades into a gentle forehead touch, teasing connection without fully embracing it.
Fight scenes retain their raw physicality. The film leans into body-to-body combat, resisting the reliance on CGI-laden sequences. One standout confrontation between Andy and Quynh unfolds in a shadowy Roman alley, layered with centuries of guilt, anger, and unspoken feelings. Pain and history drive every punch.
A new mechanic involving the transference of immortality introduces philosophical implications. Characters are forced to reckon with mortality and sacrifice. This adds a thoughtful layer to what could have been routine action fare.
Later scenes shift to a Chinese-run nuclear facility in Indonesia, where the final confrontation unfolds. High-tech weaponry, sabotage, and a climactic showdown between Andy and Discord provide visual spectacle. The long-anticipated duel between Theron and Thurman, however, lacks the emotional buildup needed to make it iconic. Action fans may still be satisfied, but those seeking narrative payoff may find it underwhelming.
The sequel hints at a third installment, ending on a quiet cliffhanger. Emotional and narrative arcs remain open, particularly around Quynh and Discord. If a trilogy capstone does materialize, fans can hope for a return to the balance of heart and spectacle that defined the first entry.
The Old Guard 2 succeeds in expanding its universe and enriching its lore. Charlize Theron delivers another compelling performance, and the film offers enough well-executed action to satisfy genre expectations. However, without Gina Prince-Bythewood’s guiding presence, the film trades cinematic soul for solid efficiency. It’s a good sequel—but not a great one.
