James Gunn's Superman review roundup: Critical praise and highlights of the new DC Universe launch
James Gunn’s latest directorial venture, Superman, featuring David Corenswet as the iconic superhero, is set to premiere in theaters on July 11. The film marks a significant reboot of the DC Universe, with Gunn at the helm as co-CEO of DC Studios. Corenswet takes on the dual role of Clark Kent and Superman, succeeding notable predecessors such as Christopher Reeve and Henry Cavill.
James Gunn’s Superman redefines the Man of Steel with fresh energy and heartfelt performances, launching a promising new chapter for the DC Universe this summer.
Warner Bros./Courtesy Everett Collection
Joining Corenswet, Rachel Brosnahan portrays the intrepid journalist Lois Lane, while Nicholas Hoult steps into the shoes of the infamous villain Lex Luthor. The cast’s performances have drawn particular praise from critics who highlight the fresh dynamics brought to these classic characters.
During the Los Angeles premiere, James Gunn shared his vision for the new Superman. He aimed to create a film that honors the fantastical elements of the comic book world—complete with giant robots and Kaiju—while also offering a deep, personal exploration of Superman’s character, relationships, and inner struggles. Gunn emphasized portraying Superman’s humanity alongside his superhuman qualities, highlighting his strengths and vulnerabilities.
Critical reception to Superman has been overwhelmingly positive, with the film holding an 85% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes as of midweek. The Hollywood Reporter’s chief film critic David Rooney commended Corenswet’s portrayal, noting his “self-irony, charm, and poignant vulnerability.” Rooney also praised Brosnahan’s Lois Lane as one of the most captivating interpretations of the character in recent memory. Although he found the film occasionally overloaded and muddled, Rooney acknowledged its relentless entertainment value and nostalgic sense of wonder.
Alissa Wilkinson of The New York Times described Gunn’s take on the Superman myth as both “sincere and goofy,” appreciating its balance of humor and mythology. She highlighted Brosnahan’s Lois Lane as a standout figure—depicted as a strong, professional reporter who defies typical damsel-in-distress stereotypes.
Collider’s senior editor Ross Bonaime labeled Superman a “magnificent feat,” applauding Gunn for combining homage to the hero’s legacy with an optimistic vision for the DC Universe’s future. Bonaime found the film’s tone refreshing in a genre often dominated by darker and more cynical superhero stories.
Brian Truitt of USA Today emphasized the film’s action sequences and emotional core. He noted that Superman’s empathy and sincerity make him an endearing hero. Truitt observed that this version of the DC Universe feels distinct from previous iterations and Marvel’s style, carrying over Gunn’s signature blend of offbeat humor and heartfelt storytelling.
Empire magazine’s Sophie Butcher offered a more critical perspective on the script, pointing out weaknesses in the villain’s characterization and some awkward dialogue. Hoult’s Lex Luthor, though energetic, was viewed as lacking depth, and Superman’s portrayal sometimes fell short of the iconic ideal.
Jake Coyle of The Associated Press highlighted Gunn’s unique style, which blends whimsy and sincerity. He acknowledged moments that may seem quirky or glib but ultimately contribute to a humanizing effect rarely seen in contemporary superhero films.
IGN’s Tom Jorgensen praised the film as a “wonderfully entertaining, heartfelt cinematic reset” for Superman and a promising foundation for the DC Universe moving forward. He singled out Corenswet’s natural performance and Hoult’s portrayal of Luthor, noting the film’s fast pace and abundant fun. Jorgensen recognized the film’s complexity but felt it was well-suited for today’s audience.
